Brick and cast-iron residential entrance with closed glass doors, a worn limestone threshold and a softly lit walnut-finished vestibule.

Lafayette Street Is Trading Its Mornings and Nights Between Two Addresses

"It gets dark, you watch the show, then everybody leaves." That's how Kevin Abbott, one of the founders of Joe's Pub, described a typical night at the theater when he spoke to Eater this September. For most of its life, 425 Lafayette Street ran on that schedule. It came alive close to curtain and went quiet once the house emptied.

Since September 15, Bar Torino has been serving coffee in the Public's lobby from 10 a.m. A block south, at 372 Lafayette, the corner where Enrique Olvera ran Atla as an all-day restaurant for nearly a decade is being rebuilt for the hours after dark. In one season, NoHo's stretch of Lafayette has traded its morning address and its late-night address.

The theater that now keeps café hours

Two spaces opened in the Public on Tuesday, September 15. The Astor sits on the mezzanine behind the lobby. Bar Torino is downstairs in the lobby itself, with more seating tucked under the mezzanine. They took over from the Library, which was the theater's previous restaurant.

Bar Torino brings the biggest change in hours. The menu runs from coffee and Italian-style café food in the morning to cocktails at night. It's open every day from 10 a.m. to 10 p.m., with no reservations and first-come, first-served seating. It's the second Bar Torino. The first is in Hudson Yards. Here's a full day at the building, using the posted hours and current menus:

  1. 10 a.m. Bar Torino opens in the lobby. A cornetto costs $5.50 and a Quiche Fiorentina $12.
  2. 5 p.m. The Astor starts dinner upstairs, every day of the week.
  3. 7 p.m. Showtime at Joe's Pub on festival nights this month.
  4. 10 p.m. Bar Torino closes. By then a Negroni downstairs has been $20 since evening service began.
  5. 11 p.m. The Astor's posted closing time.

That's thirteen hours of service in a building whose rhythm used to follow the house lights. The scale is bigger than it looks from the sidewalk. On a busy night, when the theaters and Joe's Pub are all running, more than a thousand people can pass through the building, according to Eater.

Upstairs, a dining room designed to look like it was always there

The Astor comes from a team that has been inside the Public for decades. Serge Becker, Josh Pickard, Paul Salmon and Kevin Abbott started Joe's Pub with the theater in 1998. Later the partnership grew to include Luke Ostrom and Andrew Carmellini of NoHo Hospitality. Jersey Katz and Michelle Cunha, both longtime operators, are managing partners at the Astor and Bar Torino. The theater's partners on the project are artistic director Oskar Eustis and executive director Patrick Willingham.

Becker wanted the room to feel as if it had belonged to the theater for decades. It has red banquettes, white tablecloths, wood paneling and lamps, plus photographs, posters, letters and playbills from the Public's history. André Carrilho painted a mural that wraps around the island bar. EV Grieve counted 32 people associated with the Public in it, including Lin-Manuel Miranda, Alicia Keys, David Byrne, Ntozake Shange, Suzan-Lori Parks and Sam Shepard. Carrilho also painted portraits for the dining room of founder Joseph Papp and artistic directors JoAnne Akalaitis, George C. Wolfe and Oskar Eustis.

The renovation added a 52-seat mezzanine overlooking the lobby, plus 70 seats in the dining room, 20 at the bar and a 12-seat lounge.

Angel Monge runs the kitchen with Carmellini. Their menu goes back to what the team calls a golden age of New York dining. Parlor snacks run $14 to $23, savories $18 to $25 and entrées $25 to $65. You'll find clams casino, pigs in Wellington with bourbon mustard and a French mushroom dip served with au jus. The two ends of the current dinner menu are Devilish Eggs at $14 and Steak Diane at $65, made with prime filet, mushrooms and cognac jus. Bar director Darryl Chan built the drinks list around classic New York cocktails. It includes a "From the Ice Box" section of very cold martinis, Manhattans and Bijous, plus the Charlie Chaplin, a riff on a pre-Prohibition Waldorf Astoria drink.

The Astor opens reservations 14 days ahead. When the book is full, its site offers a "Notify Me" alert.

Down the block, the all-day corner goes late

Atla opened in 2017 at 372 Lafayette, on the corner of Great Jones. It was Olvera's all-day restaurant, and Eater described it as cheaper than Cosme, though "not cheap, exactly." Over the years it became known for tortillas, salsas, aguachiles and a lobster burrito. Its last service was Sunday, May 31. "We're not going anywhere, but it's time for our next chapter," Olvera said through a spokesperson.

That next chapter is Bar Cosme. Time Out reported in July that Olvera and his Casamata team are turning the space into a nightlife-focused restaurant and cocktail bar. The idea, according to the team, is to give Cosme's after-dark buzz a home of its own. Drinks come first, but the plan also includes a full sharing menu. That means raw and lightly cooked dishes, house-made tortillas and salsas, and food cooked over an asador, a live-fire grill. Sebastián Tollius, who has worked at Eleven Madison Park and Clemente Bar, is running the cocktail program. Taller ADG, an architecture firm from Mexico City, designed the room with rich materials and an intimate feel. Grub Street says the tequila drinks are the main draw and quotes Olvera promising the "evening energy" of his Flatiron restaurant. Time Out was direct for anyone who misses Atla. "Bar Cosme won't be a replacement."

The storefront next door is also changing. Honeybrains served what it called "brain-healthy meals and juices" there until it closed in February. By June, signs for Wake and Late, a Los Angeles shop known for breakfast and lunch burritos and specialty coffee, were up in the window, and EV Grieve reported a fall opening. If it opens, the morning trade at 372 Lafayette would move into a smaller space next door while the corner turns to evenings.

Here's where all four spaces stand as of early October:

Space Address Format Status as of October 4
Bar Torino 425 Lafayette, Public Theater lobby Café and aperitivo bar Open daily, 10 a.m. to 10 p.m., walk-in only
The Astor 425 Lafayette, Public Theater mezzanine Tavern and supper club Open daily for dinner, 5 to 11 p.m.
Bar Cosme 372 Lafayette, former Atla Cocktail-led Mexican restaurant Announced for "fall," no date confirmed
Wake and Late 372 Lafayette, former Honeybrains Breakfast burritos and coffee Signage up, no date confirmed

The last two rows are still promises. Eater's September 8 fall preview listed Bar Cosme as "Opening: Fall," with no specific date, and we haven't found anything announced since. Wake and Late's own website currently lists four Los Angeles-area locations and no New York one.

October on the strip

The busier hours at the Public line up with a full October calendar in the same building and on the blocks nearby.

  • October 8 to 11. Joe's Pub hosts its sixth Habibi Festival, with a 7 p.m. show each of the four nights. The lineup includes Amir ElSaffar, Akram Abdulfattah, Nadine El Roubi, Marwa Morgan, Ameer Armaly, Laura Elkeslassy, Malika Zarra and Rasha Nahas.
  • Through October 25. Jacob Ming-Trent performs his solo show How Shakespeare Saved My Life in the Public's Shiva Theater.
  • Sunday, October 18, 10:30 a.m. to 12:30 p.m. AIA New York's calendar lists a NoHo architecture walking tour that starts at the Cooper Union Foundation Building. Stops include 40 Bond, 41 Bond, 10 Bond and the Public Theater itself. Check the date on AIA's page before you go, because the listing's web address shows a different day.

On the morning of the walking tour, Bar Torino in the Public's lobby will already have been serving coffee for half an hour by the time the group sets off from Cooper Union.

Living near Lafayette Street means your block can change overnight, and we pay attention to every one of those changes. If you're thinking about a home near the Public, Bond Street or Great Jones, DeFosset Team can walk you through the buildings around these corners. Browse Properties and tell us which stretch of NoHo you'd most like to wake up on.

Work With Us

Get assistance in determining current property value, crafting a competitive offer, writing and negotiating a contract, and much more. Contact us today.

Follow Me on Instagram