Mediterranean Revival villa with arched loggia, terracotta roof, and glowing windows reflected in a tiled pool at dusk.

Palm Beach Island's New Restaurants Are Giving Familiar Buildings New Life

If you've searched "new restaurants Palm Beach" any time in the last few months, you've read about NORA District, Avenir, Nautilus 220, and the two-restaurant bet chef David Burke placed on a single Lake Park building. All of that is real, and all of it is worth knowing if you're willing to drive across the bridge for dinner. None of it is on the island.

Here, on the three-mile strip that runs from Royal Poinciana Way down to Worth Avenue, the island's recent dining news is countable on one hand. And none of it added square footage to a growing scene. Each opening took a building the island already knew, sometimes for a century, and gave it a different life. If you live here, that distinction matters more than any county-wide roundup, because it changes how you should be reading every "hottest restaurants" list that lumps the island in with the mainland's expansion.

The Playhouse Finally Faces the Water

Royal Poinciana Plaza has been a fixture on Cocoanut Row since the late 1950s, a landmarked property designed by architect John Volk with two courtyards and roughly 180,000 square feet of retail space built to echo Europe's grand shopping arcades. For decades it has held Sant Ambroeus, the Milanese caffè that's been serving its Principessa cake there since 2016, along with a rotating cast of galleries and boutiques.

What it never had, until January 2026, was a restaurant that put its dining room directly over the Intracoastal. Tutto Mare changed that, opening at the Plaza's Playhouse building as the vision of Gabby Karan de Felice, daughter of designer Donna Karan, and the sibling operation to Tutto il Giorno, the Hamptons group with locations in East Hampton, Southampton, and Sag Harbor. The menu runs seafood towers, branzino, and cioppino in a room built for up to 200 guests. It is, by every account from people who've been watching this plaza for years, the first time a restaurant here has made the water the point rather than the backdrop.

The Name Nobody Expected Back

Two blocks off Worth Avenue, a different kind of return happened. The building at the corner most recently known as The Chesterfield opened in 1926 as the Lido-Venice, was renamed The Vineta within a couple of years, and held that name for nearly fifty years before it became The Chesterfield under a different hotel group. For more than three decades under that name, its ground floor housed the Leopard Lounge, a nightspot known island-wide for leopard-print carpeting, strong martinis, and regulars who reportedly included Rod Stewart passing through and Lauren Bacall staying upstairs.

British investors David and Simon Reuben's Reuben Brothers acquired the building in 2022 and handed the redesign to Paris-based designer Tino Zervudachi. It reopened on March 2, 2026, under its original name, as The Vineta Hotel, the first U.S. property for Oetker Hotels, the German family-owned group behind Hotel du Cap-Eden-Roc and Le Bristol Paris.

The restaurant inside, Coco's, doesn't try to recreate the Leopard Lounge. It leans Mediterranean, with a courtyard done in coral tones and a red Italian marble bar. But the ceiling above the dining room still holds a hidden leopard motif, a quiet nod to the room's previous life. Executive chef Brian Rodriguez built the menu with Hotel du Cap-Eden-Roc's own chef Sébastien Broda, which is why you'll find Steak Diane made with Australian Wagyu ribeye and an Eden Roc sea bass with fennel puree on a Palm Beach menu, both pulled straight from the Antibes property's own repertoire, according to Forbes's coverage of the opening. The broader tourism picture is notable, too: visitation in Palm Beach was up 8 percent between 2024 and 2025, reaching a record 10.7 million visitors.

Sunrise Avenue's New Room

The third piece of the island's recent dining news arrived a little earlier and with less architectural baggage. The Polo Room opened on Sunrise Avenue in December 2025, co-owned by Argentine polo star Nacho Figueras, built around a continental menu with Argentine touches: prime steaks, seafood towers, a wine and cocktail list built for the kind of dinner that turns into a late one. It's the newest name on a short list, and it already has the kind of reservation difficulty that tells you it's been absorbed into the rotation rather than treated as a novelty.

What This Actually Means If You Live Here

Put those three together and a pattern shows up that the county-wide "hottest restaurants" pieces tend to flatten. The island's most talked-about new restaurant this year, Emelina, the 16-seat tasting counter that became the first Cuban restaurant in the world to earn a Michelin star, isn't even on the island. It's a Michelin story about West Palm Beach. On Palm Beach itself, the island's dining footprint didn't expand. It got reallocated between buildings the town has known for generations.

That's worth knowing before you plan your next dinner, because it means the island's older anchors haven't gone anywhere. Café Boulud is still Café Boulud. Buccan has held its reputation as the hardest reservation on the island for well over a decade and hasn't loosened its grip. Renato's walled garden courtyard on Worth Avenue is still one of the more romantic settings in town, decades in. What changed is what sits between those fixed points: a theater building now serving cioppino over the Intracoastal, a hundred-year-old hotel with its original name and a leopard secret on the ceiling, and a Sunrise Avenue room with a polo star's name on the lease.

There's also a practical window closing fast. Flavor South Florida, the region's restaurant month, runs through September 30 with more than one hundred participating restaurants offering prix-fixe lunch, brunch, and dinner menus. If you've been meaning to try Tutto Mare or Coco's without committing to a full à la carte night, this is the cheapest version of that test drive you'll get until next year. There's also a Stephen Starr steakhouse reportedly in the works for 151 Worth Avenue, though any opening there is still well down the road, so the island's short list of new rooms should stay short for a while yet.

None of this requires you to do anything. You already live here. But the next time a headline promises "Palm Beach's hottest new restaurants" and lists four restaurants you'd need a car to reach, you'll know the difference between the island's actual news and the county's.


Curious what else has quietly changed around your corner of Palm Beach, or thinking about what your own address is worth in a year when the neighborhood's headlines keep pointing across the bridge? The DeFosset Team knows this stretch of Florida as well as they know Tribeca, and they're always up for a conversation about either coast.

Work With Us

Get assistance in determining current property value, crafting a competitive offer, writing and negotiating a contract, and much more. Contact us today.

Follow Me on Instagram